mush wrote:thx for the information its great to know . One thing im wondering is how the relativity of these attributes are used by scouts ? Or is it just a couple of the attributes that are applied to scouts like judging potiential and ability ? does anybody actually know ? or is this just myth .... i have read the manual btw!
There is much that is know by a few database editors and a few who've done significant playtesting, but I think only Riz knows
exactly how everything is designed to work and what is supposed to affect what (especially the weighting of different factors), and when it is that an Attribute has no affect at all
I'm not exactly sure what you mean by "how is the relativity of these
Attributes used?" but I'm thinking you're probably wondering "what actually affects scouting? is it just the Judging Ability/Judging Potential
Attributes?"
Judging Ability/Potential are going to be the primary factor in a Scouts ability to "scout" (the giving of opinions/recommendations/ratings regarding players that were scouted).
Job specific factors like "coaching"
Attributes have no affect on "scouting" but some of those "general/personality"
Attributes might have some affect on the end result of scouting (the opinions/recommendations/ratings)
IIRC Determination is thought to have an affect on scouting, but exactly what I don't know (more accurate faster? more players seen? or...

)
I'd like to think Adaptability has some affect on scouting, in that a Scout with low Adaptability should struggle or even be unable to Scout in foreign/unfamiliar countries, but in reality I don't think this is the case.....same with
Attributes like Coaching Defenseman having an affect on scouting: I wish they did (like if a Scout had a high Coaching D and lower Coaching G/Coaching F
Attributes, their scouting reports on defenseman would be more complete/accurate than their scouting reports on goalies/forwards), but it doesn't work this way.....another area of
Attributes that could but doesn't have an affect AFAIK (but should IMO) is that of coaching style
Attributes
It seems to me to be certain that CA isn't as relevant for Scouts as it is for some other
Staff like a Coach or GM, as they have far fewer "relevant
Attributes" among those
Attributes that are not general/personality (I think it's just Judging Ability/Judging Potential), so Scouts could have very different CAs but have the same values in Judging Ability/Judging Potential + the few other relevant general/personality
Attributes & thus be "the same" in terms of scouting ability