Minstrel Hockey League 2010-11
Forum rules
PLEASE NOTE: ADVERTISING A LEAGUE/COMPETITION/WEB SITE/FORUM IS NO LONGER PERMITTED ANYWHERE ON THE BLUE LINE. We have had too many people take liberties with this privilege; signing up simply to advertise their site and not actually contributing to the community. We also see a lot of bumping of threads which is really just spamming the site. Anybody that advertises anything on TBL will be permanently banned for spamming.
PLEASE NOTE: ADVERTISING A LEAGUE/COMPETITION/WEB SITE/FORUM IS NO LONGER PERMITTED ANYWHERE ON THE BLUE LINE. We have had too many people take liberties with this privilege; signing up simply to advertise their site and not actually contributing to the community. We also see a lot of bumping of threads which is really just spamming the site. Anybody that advertises anything on TBL will be permanently banned for spamming.
- batdad
- The Great One
- Posts: 12616
- Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:46 pm
- Custom Rank: Mr Technology
- Favourite Team: Syracuse Bulldogs.
- Location: Look behind you, you peon
OK boys. We have now got to the 2 week point in our game. We have all had lots of time to evaluate our rosters. It is time to start looking to see what else is out there. What are you happy with? What are you needing to improve?
There are slim pickins on the waiver and free agent wire this season. Basically, warm bodies.
So....some of you have already, but for those who have not could you Please go in and set up your trade blocks.
I am sure noone can be 100% happy with their team. Lets try and see if we can improve them all a bit. Time for the trade searches to begin. When it comes to deals with me, please do not just REJECT things I offer.make a counter..I am not going to give you the best offer the first time, in many cases..although I do try and get things close to value for value. If you are unhappy with an offer...don't just reject...reject and counter...add a note as to what you would rather have (Don't ask for Iginla for a dman though)
You guys know the drill...I work to make my team better, just as you do. So...please bring on some deals!!!
There are slim pickins on the waiver and free agent wire this season. Basically, warm bodies.
So....some of you have already, but for those who have not could you Please go in and set up your trade blocks.
I am sure noone can be 100% happy with their team. Lets try and see if we can improve them all a bit. Time for the trade searches to begin. When it comes to deals with me, please do not just REJECT things I offer.make a counter..I am not going to give you the best offer the first time, in many cases..although I do try and get things close to value for value. If you are unhappy with an offer...don't just reject...reject and counter...add a note as to what you would rather have (Don't ask for Iginla for a dman though)
You guys know the drill...I work to make my team better, just as you do. So...please bring on some deals!!!
- McQwak
- Stanley Cup Winner
- Posts: 1439
- Joined: Mon Nov 05, 2007 1:59 pm
- Custom Rank: Now with capital letters!
- Location: Prague, Czech rep.
- B. Stinson
- TBL Admin Team
- Posts: 5131
- Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 11:22 pm
- Favourite Team: Philadelphia Flyers
- Location: Telford, PA
To be honest, I don't think we know know what ESPN does. They have an option for one tie-breaker, which I have set to be Goals, but beyond that, it's a mystery.McQwak wrote:Why is my last matchup (Prague Dead Parrots vs. Chicago Sun Bears) counted as win? The final score was 5-5-2, both teams scored 13 goals![]()
I don't complain, Joehelmer shouldJust want to understand it.
We had a moment last year where this happened to CatchUp, and the only thing we could conclude is that it went to alphabetical order. However, it appears that your match-up counters that, and gave you the win (P vs. C).
Unfortunately, I'm stumped on how double-ties are handled.

- batdad
- The Great One
- Posts: 12616
- Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:46 pm
- Custom Rank: Mr Technology
- Favourite Team: Syracuse Bulldogs.
- Location: Look behind you, you peon
So I was wondering. We should have a
"Who won this trade thread?" Then at the end of the year we can look at it and see.
Trade #1
Takes effect Tue Oct 26.
Chicago Sun Bears trade: Jeff Carter C, Phi and Stephane Robidas D Dal
to
Burnaby Black Ice for: Mikko Koivu C, Min and Michael Ryder RW, Bos
I of course think I won. Joe clearly thinks he won. What do the others think?
"Who won this trade thread?" Then at the end of the year we can look at it and see.
Trade #1
Takes effect Tue Oct 26.
Chicago Sun Bears trade: Jeff Carter C, Phi and Stephane Robidas D Dal
to
Burnaby Black Ice for: Mikko Koivu C, Min and Michael Ryder RW, Bos
I of course think I won. Joe clearly thinks he won. What do the others think?
- Manimal
- TBL Admin Team
- Posts: 6344
- Joined: Thu Apr 24, 2008 4:01 am
- Custom Rank: EHM Rosters Man
- Favourite Team: Djurgårdens IF
- Location: Karlstad, Sweden
I agree with the Commish'. That was a rip-off!batdad wrote:So I was wondering. We should have a
"Who won this trade thread?" Then at the end of the year we can look at it and see.
Trade #1
Takes effect Tue Oct 26.
Chicago Sun Bears trade: Jeff Carter C, Phi and Stephane Robidas D Dal
to
Burnaby Black Ice for: Mikko Koivu C, Min and Michael Ryder RW, Bos
I of course think I won. Joe clearly thinks he won. What do the others think?
Joe, what were you thinking?

- joehelmer
- TBL Mod Team
- Posts: 3483
- Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 4:45 pm
- Favourite Team: Djurgården (SHL)
- Location: Sweden
- McQwak
- Stanley Cup Winner
- Posts: 1439
- Joined: Mon Nov 05, 2007 1:59 pm
- Custom Rank: Now with capital letters!
- Location: Prague, Czech rep.
- B. Stinson
- TBL Admin Team
- Posts: 5131
- Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 11:22 pm
- Favourite Team: Philadelphia Flyers
- Location: Telford, PA
- batdad
- The Great One
- Posts: 12616
- Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:46 pm
- Custom Rank: Mr Technology
- Favourite Team: Syracuse Bulldogs.
- Location: Look behind you, you peon
So..I just did something I found interesting. I went through my roster of 23 to figure out how my guys got to my team. Here are my findings
9 Players drafted by the Black Ice...6 in 2010, 3 in 2009 (Marleau, Iginla,Luongo)
5 players acquired through trades (Seabrook, Lidstrom and Bourque in 2009, and Carter and Robidas 2010)
FA/Waivers-9 guys currently on roster, for which there is a constant rotation in and out except for Callahan, Boynton and maybe Gorges.)
Of my 2010 draftees...not one of them is going to challenge for a keeper spot..save maybe Visnovsky vs a possibly retiring Lidstrom.
Oh and if...big IF....freaking ESPN allows Marleau to keep his LW slot this season, could be on between Marleau and Bourque. Will be on between Carter and Marleau anyway.
9 Players drafted by the Black Ice...6 in 2010, 3 in 2009 (Marleau, Iginla,Luongo)
5 players acquired through trades (Seabrook, Lidstrom and Bourque in 2009, and Carter and Robidas 2010)
FA/Waivers-9 guys currently on roster, for which there is a constant rotation in and out except for Callahan, Boynton and maybe Gorges.)
Of my 2010 draftees...not one of them is going to challenge for a keeper spot..save maybe Visnovsky vs a possibly retiring Lidstrom.
Oh and if...big IF....freaking ESPN allows Marleau to keep his LW slot this season, could be on between Marleau and Bourque. Will be on between Carter and Marleau anyway.
- CatchUp
- TBL Mod Team
- Posts: 1879
- Joined: Sun Dec 10, 2006 9:01 pm
- Custom Rank: CEO Of Avatars Inc.
- Location: Toronto, ON
Joe that is an awful trade dude - no offense. Carter is on a tear, so you'd better hope Koivu rips it up because Ryder is a bum. Still bitter because of his days on the Habs.
That said, I'm going to head over and update my trade block now, so maybe I'll be the next one on the receiving end of a batdad rip off. Hahaha.

That said, I'm going to head over and update my trade block now, so maybe I'll be the next one on the receiving end of a batdad rip off. Hahaha.

- batdad
- The Great One
- Posts: 12616
- Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:46 pm
- Custom Rank: Mr Technology
- Favourite Team: Syracuse Bulldogs.
- Location: Look behind you, you peon
Joe---Couple things
1. Don't you worry about Catch Up's little opinion. He is having a tough time this week. He is upset because the day of the trade Mikko Koivu had an assist and 4 PIMs for me. Then the next day Jeff Carter lit up Buffalo with 1G and 2A and 6 shots, and Stephane Robidas took 15 min in PIM. And the score right now is 11-0-1 for me. So he is panicking.
That being said....point 2 is something you need to look at Joe.
2. You have Bill Guerin and Sheldon Souray on your roster. Neither of them is playing in the NHL. Neither is expected to be any time soon. I would be getting rid of them.
CatchUp--Stop worrying it is early early. You have 10 guys tonight, I have 5. But...have a look at your trade proposals...
1. Don't you worry about Catch Up's little opinion. He is having a tough time this week. He is upset because the day of the trade Mikko Koivu had an assist and 4 PIMs for me. Then the next day Jeff Carter lit up Buffalo with 1G and 2A and 6 shots, and Stephane Robidas took 15 min in PIM. And the score right now is 11-0-1 for me. So he is panicking.
That being said....point 2 is something you need to look at Joe.
2. You have Bill Guerin and Sheldon Souray on your roster. Neither of them is playing in the NHL. Neither is expected to be any time soon. I would be getting rid of them.
CatchUp--Stop worrying it is early early. You have 10 guys tonight, I have 5. But...have a look at your trade proposals...

- batdad
- The Great One
- Posts: 12616
- Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:46 pm
- Custom Rank: Mr Technology
- Favourite Team: Syracuse Bulldogs.
- Location: Look behind you, you peon
Just a quick note for Mr. Stinson...
The owner of Kent Mighty Turnips is apparently even more inactive than last season's owner of this team (cough*archi*cough). I have tried for two weeks now to get trade responses from him and have nothing. I also have noticed that his lineup has not been changed or adjusted for some time...I believe that this is becoming a concern.
If the owner of the Turnips is around---Could you please please do something? Show us you are alive?
The owner of Kent Mighty Turnips is apparently even more inactive than last season's owner of this team (cough*archi*cough). I have tried for two weeks now to get trade responses from him and have nothing. I also have noticed that his lineup has not been changed or adjusted for some time...I believe that this is becoming a concern.
If the owner of the Turnips is around---Could you please please do something? Show us you are alive?
- kuulapaa
- Stanley Cup Winner
- Posts: 1410
- Joined: Fri Apr 28, 2006 6:14 pm
- Custom Rank: General Roster Soreness
- Favourite Team: Tampereen Ilves
- SBHL Team: Los Angeles Kings
- Location: Finland
What if he's acting the only way he knows after he saw what happened to Joe when you made a trade proposition to him and ripped his lungs out? He's playing dead and waiting for you to go awaybatdad wrote:I have tried for two weeks now to get trade responses from him and have nothing. I also have noticed that his lineup has not been changed or adjusted for some time...I believe that this is becoming a concern.
If the owner of the Turnips is around---Could you please please do something? Show us you are alive?

- corinthian
- Minor League
- Posts: 253
- Joined: Sat Jun 23, 2007 5:10 am
- Location: São Paulo, Brazil
- joehelmer
- TBL Mod Team
- Posts: 3483
- Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 4:45 pm
- Favourite Team: Djurgården (SHL)
- Location: Sweden
- McQwak
- Stanley Cup Winner
- Posts: 1439
- Joined: Mon Nov 05, 2007 1:59 pm
- Custom Rank: Now with capital letters!
- Location: Prague, Czech rep.
- batdad
- The Great One
- Posts: 12616
- Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:46 pm
- Custom Rank: Mr Technology
- Favourite Team: Syracuse Bulldogs.
- Location: Look behind you, you peon
Yes...and the record was set and tied by myself and Marsac. Danny Heatley ruined what could have been a perfect game for me. Well...Heatley and the Ducks. had Anaheim managed 2 more goals or had Marleau scored the third goal instead of 5th...I would have won 12-0-0.
Trade update:
My new guys since Oct 26:
Jeff Carter 3g 3a +3 2PIM 2PPP 0 SHP 1 GWG 16 SOG 3 Blocks
S Robidas 0G 1a +1 15PIM 0 0 0 3 SOG 1 Block
TOTAL 3g 4a +4 17PIM 2PPP 0 SHP 1GWG 19SOG 4 Blocks
Mi Koivu 1g 1a E 2PIM 1PPP 0SHP 1 GWG 7 SOG 1Block
Mi Ryder 0g 1a +1 0PIM 0PP 0SHP 0GWG 5 SOG 0block
TOTAL 1g 2a +1 2PIM 1PPP 0SHP 1GWG 12SOG 1Block
Trade update:
My new guys since Oct 26:
Jeff Carter 3g 3a +3 2PIM 2PPP 0 SHP 1 GWG 16 SOG 3 Blocks
S Robidas 0G 1a +1 15PIM 0 0 0 3 SOG 1 Block
TOTAL 3g 4a +4 17PIM 2PPP 0 SHP 1GWG 19SOG 4 Blocks
Mi Koivu 1g 1a E 2PIM 1PPP 0SHP 1 GWG 7 SOG 1Block
Mi Ryder 0g 1a +1 0PIM 0PP 0SHP 0GWG 5 SOG 0block
TOTAL 1g 2a +1 2PIM 1PPP 0SHP 1GWG 12SOG 1Block
- joehelmer
- TBL Mod Team
- Posts: 3483
- Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 4:45 pm
- Favourite Team: Djurgården (SHL)
- Location: Sweden
You really had to rub that in, didn't you?batdad wrote:
Trade update:
My new guys since Oct 26:
Jeff Carter 3g 3a +3 2PIM 2PPP 0 SHP 1 GWG 16 SOG 3 Blocks
S Robidas 0G 1a +1 15PIM 0 0 0 3 SOG 1 Block
TOTAL 3g 4a +4 17PIM 2PPP 0 SHP 1GWG 19SOG 4 Blocks
Mi Koivu 1g 1a E 2PIM 1PPP 0SHP 1 GWG 7 SOG 1Block
Mi Ryder 0g 1a +1 0PIM 0PP 0SHP 0GWG 5 SOG 0block
TOTAL 1g 2a +1 2PIM 1PPP 0SHP 1GWG 12SOG 1Block

- batdad
- The Great One
- Posts: 12616
- Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:46 pm
- Custom Rank: Mr Technology
- Favourite Team: Syracuse Bulldogs.
- Location: Look behind you, you peon
- B. Stinson
- TBL Admin Team
- Posts: 5131
- Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 11:22 pm
- Favourite Team: Philadelphia Flyers
- Location: Telford, PA
Sorry for the late reply, but you're correct: our roster requirements are our minimums.corinthian wrote:I've been looking at the trading block and I noted that Chicago Sun Bears has only 5 d-men on roster. Aren't every team supposed to have at leat 6 d-men?
ESPN will allow us to drop below the current roster requirements, but we still require teams to at least meet 4 LW, 4 C, 4 RW, 6 D, and 2G.