batdad wrote:If they were in the ECHL...they are not very good. That is where the guys go who are just never going to make it.
Well for one thing, guys played in the ECHL this past season that wouldn't normally due to the lockout, so that's one thing to consider. That kinda' applies all-around and is why some teams that usually don't have success in the ECHL had it this year.
You kinda' completely missed what I was talking about though. I was referring to VAN's AHL team, not necessarily VAN themselves. I don't know if any of those guys will ever see time in VAN (Sauve has already I guess), though I think Archibald has the best shot. Trust me, some teams send absolute garbage to their ECHL teams (Hi New Jersey and Philly, shoot NJ sends garbage to their AHL team too it seems)... some do OK considering their poor org (NYI, can't bash or praise them)... and some seem to send clearly better guys down and view it still as a developmental ground (SJ, VAN). We've seen all types in Kalamazoo in just a handful of seasons. VAN's guys they've sent are definitely of a better quality and I'm betting if they're moving their AAA affiliate they probably might want the same with AA, so a lot of K-Wing fans will be kinda' sad to see them go.
Honestly, VAN of all teams is probably one of the *better* examples of ECHL guys making it even. IIRC they have several guys on the regular NHL roster that have spent significant ECHL time in the past, including Alex Burrows. As a Red Wings fan, I can tell you their guys in Toledo (aside from goalies) basically never make it or have any hope, because they view Toledo as for developing Grand Rapids guys, not developing guys for Detroit. Luckily for Toledo fans, they also have Chicago/Rockford as an affiliate, who sends a bit better players down IMO.
Anyhow my point was I think VAN's farm team, wherever they end up, won't be a doormat. I won't ever badmouth VAN's system now that I've seen the differences in philosophy and how systems are handled.
CeeBee wrote:I think Brendan Gaunce is also a pretty good prospect and maybe Defensman Corrado but yeah, Gill has hugely mismanaged the prospect end of things by trading young players(Grabner) draft picks(you name em) and of course the one thing he controls least is where the team drafts BUT Detroit seems to do OK with low first round picks( you have to keep em to have a chance).
Well, DET often then trades those late firsts DOWN even for extra picks later. That was a hot topic of discussion this past trade deadline when Holland stated he didn't want to part with "valuable firsts" when he did so last year for Kyle Quincey and then also has a rep for trading them down anyways and not actually picking with them. It did not set well with many Wings fans as a reasoning, and if he trades down again this next draft I expect for a lot more calls for him to be fired and then I won't really blame them (Holland's words not matching his actions and all).