New NHL trophies?

Want to discuss any hockey related issues? Heard some interesting news? Watched a great game? Heard an interesting rumor or quote? Talk about it here! CONTAINS SPOILERS!
Post Reply
User avatar
Shadd666
Super Mario
Posts: 2996
Joined: Mon Mar 27, 2006 5:47 pm
Custom Rank: Smiley Crazy Goodwill Ambassador!
Location: Toulouse (France)

New NHL trophies?

Post by Shadd666 »

Found on NHL.com
Everybody loves trophies. This is especially true in hockey, which lays claim to some of the best pieces of hardware in all of sports.

The Stanley Cup is, undeniably, the most lusted after trophy in all of sports, pined over by every athlete fortunate enough to pull on an NHL sweater. The Conn Smythe Trophy, awarded to the MVP of the playoffs, is also a pretty sweet trinket, sure to spruce up any display case.

Hockey even gets its individual awards right.

The Maurice "Rocket" Richard Trophy, awarded to the League's top goal scorer, is not only easy on the eyes, but honors one of the game's all-time great scorers. The Art Ross Trophy, with pucks on the pedestal detailing past winners, is the perfect reward for leading the League in scoring. The Frank J. Selke Trophy, awarded to the League's best defensive forward, is a classic with a beautiful two-handled bowl atop a wooden support.

But as good as all these trophies are, it is Crashing the Net's opinion that there are not enough of them. There is so much about the game that should be celebrated that cannot be accommodated by the 16 individual trophies now on offer.

So, this week's Opening Faceoff proposes 18 potential pieces of hardware that could be added to the NHL's permanent trophy case. None of these new suggestions are offered to lessen the mystique of the trophies already on hand that, through decades of ownership by the game's best and brightest players, have been woven into the fabric of the game.

Rather, they are additions meant to further celebrate aspects of the game that currently are too specific to garner end-of-the-season accolades. The first five suggested by CTN could easily be added to the already established first-tier of trophies currently handed out.

The other 13, meanwhile, would be considered secondary awards that could be handed out before the actual televised Awards Show in June, much in the same way that many of the lesser Academy Awards - sound mixing, visual effects, animated short film and the like - are awarded before the gala Academy Awards television special.

These new trophies, named after the players that best exemplified the skill being honored, would also celebrate the achievements of many recently retired players who should be remembered by future generations of fans.

Now, onto a description of each of these awards, followed by who would most likely win each if they awarded at this June's Award show.

Montreal Forum Award - CTN pictures a handsome bronzed replica of the defunct Montreal Forum, perhaps the most intimidating building the NHL has ever known. The team with the best home record would receive this award each year. 2007 winner: Nashville Predators.

Pelle Lindbergh Memorial Award - Philadelphia's Pelle Lindbergh was on his way to greatness when a tragic car accident cut his life short. He was just 26 at the time. This trophy, which would feature Lindbergh guarding his net, would be given annually to the best goalie in the NHL under the age of 27. 2007 winner: Rick DiPietro, New York Islanders.

Steve Yzerman Award - The trophy would be a bronzed representation of Yzerman's Detroit jersey, with the 'C' prominent in the top-left quadrant. Yzerman, who retired before the start of this season, served as captain of the Wings for 20 years, the longest tenure of any captain in NHL history. It would be given annually to the best captain in the NHL. 2007 winner: Joe Sakic, Colorado Avalanche.

Bobby Orr Award - This trophy would be among the prettiest of the bunch, depicting Orr's Stanley Cup-winning goal celebration as he flew through the air, his outstretched body parallel to the ice surface with his stick raised triumphantly. During his time with Boston, Orr revolutionized the way the game was played and he is the only defenseman to ever lead the League in scoring, doing it twice. This award would be given annually to the defensemen with the most points. 2007 winner: Nicklas Lidstrom, Detroit Red Wings.

Wayne Gretzky Golden Stick - A solid-gold, actual-size replica of the Titan-brand stick made famous by Gretzky would go annually to the player with the most assists in the NHL. Gretzky accumulated 1,963 assists during his legendary career, 714 more than his next-closest pursuer. 2007 winner: Sidney Crosby, Pittsburgh Penguins.

Scott Stevens Trophy - This trophy would feature a bent-low Stevens administering one of his patented open-ice hits to an anonymous opponent, portraying the savage nature of the player that spent more than a decade as the most-feared hitter in the game. It would be given annually to the most intimidating hitter in the NHL. 2007 winner: Dion Phaneuf, Calgary Flames.

Cam Neely Trophy - A small statuette of Neely about to be crosschecked across his No. 8 as he fires off a shot from just outside the opponent's net would be the reward for the player adjudged to be the best power forward each season. Neely, a recent inductee into the Hall of Fame, could do it all before injuries ended his brilliant career prematurely. 2007 winner: Ryan Smyth, Edmonton Oilers.

Ron Tugnutt Award - The diminutive Tugnutt was always one of CTN's favorite goalies, a place secured when he made 70 saves against Boston in a 3-3 tie back in 1991. He played 16 years with eight NHL franchises, serving mostly as a backup. "Tugger" epitomized what a good second-string goalie should be. 2007 winner: Niklas Backstrom, Minnesota Wild.

Don Cherry Suit - Everyone is familiar with Don Cherry's bombastic nature as the star of CBC's Coach's Corner, but Cherry was also pretty colorful during his time behind NHL benches in Colorado and Boston. He was a star as a coach, something that is all-too-rare these days. The winner of this award for the League's most charismatic coach, voted on by the NHL beat writers, would get a custom-tailored suit designed by Don Cherry himself. 2007 winner: John Tortorella, Tampa Bay Lightning.

Bob Probert Belt - This award would be a championship belt like the ones worn by champions in boxing and it would be awarded each year to the NHL's most-feared fighter, the status Probert held annually during his prime in Detroit. The vote would be among all NHL players with at least three fighting majors that year. 2007 winner: Georges Laraque, Phoenix Coyotes.

Patrick Roy Trophy - This award would be given to the goalie judged to be most difficult to beat in big-game situations and would be voted on by the League's goalies. For now, it would be named after the retired Roy, who is considered the best "money" goalie of his generation. Eventually, however, the name would have to be changed to Martin Brodeur, the current best "big-game" goalie out there and a man that threatens to break most, if not all, of Roy's records. 2007 winner: Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils.

Theo Fleury Award - At 5-foot-6, Theo Fleury was one of the best little men to play the game at the NHL level. Despite questions about his lack of size in what was, at the time, a big-man's game, Fleury silenced his many critics with eight seasons of 30 or more goals during his NHL career. The award, however, would be expanded to encompass players 5-foot-10 and under to assure a representative pool of candidates each year. 2007 winner: Martin St. Louis, Tampa Bay Lightning.

Adam Oates Award - Somehow, Adam Oates was passed up in the NHL Entry Draft and forced to sign a free-agent deal after graduating from college. He used the draft snub as motivation and by the time he was done he was just the eighth player in the history of the NHL to finish his career with more than 1,000 assists. 2007 winner: Daniel Briere, Buffalo Sabres.

Craig Ludwig Kneepad -- This award would go annually to the League's most prolific shotblocker. It is named after defensemen Craig Ludwig, who perfected this art during a distinguished 17-year NHL career that included two Stanley Cup championships. He is famous for the extra-wide shinpads he wore throughout his career, pieces of equipment that now reside at the Hockey Hall of Fame. The winner of this award would receive a replica of those shin pads to commemorate the achievement. 2007 winner: Anton Volchenkov, Ottawa Senators.

Tiger Williams Award - Dave "Tiger" Williams is the most penalized man in NHL history, amassing 3,966 minutes in the sin bin during a wild 13-year career. What better man to represent the award for the penalty-minute leader each season. The trophy would be a replica of a penalty box with a door that could be manually opened and closed. 2007 winner: Ben Eager, Philadelphia Flyers.

Terry Sawchuk Memorial Award - Sawchuk holds the record for most shutouts by a goalie in a career, a mark of 103 that was thought untouchable until recently. He had four seasons where he recorded double-digit shutout totals. 2007 winner: Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils.

Wayne Connelly Award - With the shootout taking on added importance since its introduction last year, it's about time that specialists in this tie-breaking procedure be honored. The award would be named after Connelly, who scored the first successful overtime penalty shot in the history of the NHL back in 1968 while a member of the Minnesota North Stars. 2007 winner: Mikko Koivu, Minnesota Wild.

Adam Graves Award -- Throughout his distinguished career, Graves always played second fiddle to stronger personalities on his teams. Yet, there was rarely a player more valuable than Graves, who played with a quiet determination, on any team he represented. This award, voted on by the NHLPA, would go to the player adjudged to make the biggest contribution possible in the quietest manner. 2007 winner: Chris Mason, Nashville Predators.
:thdn: :roll:
User avatar
CatchUp
TBL Mod Team
Posts: 1879
Joined: Sun Dec 10, 2006 9:01 pm
Custom Rank: CEO Of Avatars Inc.
Location: Toronto, ON

Post by CatchUp »

A couple of them seem ok, but to be honest, I got bored and stopped reading after a while. :roll:

I don't think the NHL NEEDS to add awards. I would like to see the Bobby Orr award though, that would be sweet. :thup:

Cheers.
User avatar
batdad
The Great One
Posts: 12616
Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:46 pm
Custom Rank: Mr Technology
Favourite Team: Syracuse Bulldogs.
Location: Look behind you, you peon

Post by batdad »

And the NFL and NBA should add 95 trophies each. At least one of which would be for the best arrest scene at a game, and the best arrest scene not at a game.

MLB should come up with 2 new awards, one for each league...best hitter on roids..then the other one (MVP?) could be best hitter not actually proven to be on roids. Must have a Barry Bonds exception...cause it has never been proven, but everyone knows.

Christ, lets have the acadamy awards. Best Receptionist would be a good one.

Note: Today is an odd day, I am agreeing with CatchUp again. Arggh. Start talking Habs bud...I need to fire a shot or two your way.

And is that blogger really Gary Buttman? Cause I am sure that he has polls coming out of his arse that says it would be a great idea. 350 trophies....because there are 350 players. make sure Marc Chouinard gets one then!
User avatar
E5150_ca
All-Star
Posts: 1013
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2005 2:56 am
Custom Rank: PrO Canada!
Location: Toronto

Post by E5150_ca »

Why don't we just give a trophy to every single goalie in the NHL and be done with it. :roll:
User avatar
Shadd666
Super Mario
Posts: 2996
Joined: Mon Mar 27, 2006 5:47 pm
Custom Rank: Smiley Crazy Goodwill Ambassador!
Location: Toulouse (France)

Post by Shadd666 »

I wouldn't mind about the Bobby Orr award. Sounds fair. Maybe Gretzky's one too. But that's all. Other ones are BS.
User avatar
holydogg
Checking Line
Posts: 510
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 12:13 am
Location: Montreal

Post by holydogg »

why not a Turner Stevenson cement gloves Memorial for the best 1st round pick roleplayer?
:bs:
User avatar
B. Stinson
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 5131
Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 11:22 pm
Favourite Team: Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Telford, PA

Post by B. Stinson »

A couple of them seem ok, but to be honest, I got bored and stopped reading after a while.
Same here. It started out pretty well... but then after the first hundred or so proposed awards, it seemed like they were just desperate for ideas. Though, with that being said, I'm surprised there was no "Golden Eyes Award" - Awarded to the player who blinked the least through-out the season. :-o

P.S. I think I already hear Minty's shouts of extreme joy over the Wayne Connelly Award. ...The inception of that one would most-likely solidify the shootout in the NHL rulebook. :thdn: ... if it's not already solidified by Bettman's madness.
User avatar
bruins72
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 14513
Joined: Fri Jan 20, 2006 3:13 pm
Custom Rank: Challenge Guy
Favourite Team: Boston Bruins
Location: Taunton, MA

Post by bruins72 »

Most of them are pretty bad. It's like they want to give everyone a trophy for participating so nobody feels bad. Plus, the descriptions they gave for most of them would make the trophies over-elaborate and maybe even fragile. A trophy should be a solid figure, not a scene.

A couple are decent. I like the Bobby Orr one... and not just because it's named after Orr. I'd like to see the Norris not just be give to the highest scoring defenseman. I'd rather see that honor go to the best all-around defenseman or maybe even defensive defenseman. Have a separate one for scoring.
User avatar
holydogg
Checking Line
Posts: 510
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 12:13 am
Location: Montreal

Post by holydogg »

bruins72 wrote: A couple are decent. I like the Bobby Orr one... and not just because it's named after Orr. I'd like to see the Norris not just be give to the highest scoring defenseman. I'd rather see that honor go to the best all-around defenseman or maybe even defensive defenseman. Have a separate one for scoring.
Like the Art Ross (virually all the time except for .. Bobby Orr), Maurice Richard and the Selke for the forwards. I totally agree. 2 trophies for D-men is a good idea. the goalies already have 3 awards.
User avatar
Minstrel
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 6527
Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2005 11:17 am
Custom Rank: Minty
Favourite Team: Chicago Blackhawks
Location: Chicago, Illinois

Post by Minstrel »

This was definitely written by Bettman, still no idea about he traditions that make the game great. Not to mention why NHL trophies in particular are so cool, as they are all tied to great trailblazers and not sponsored or "renamed" with corporate sponsors or "updated" with new players to best represent them. :roll:

There are only two trophy changes that need to be made:

1. Outlaw the "Bud Light Plus Minus" award as it makes for a bad precedent, leading to more Mark Messier Cold-FX Leadership Awards etc. The +/- award can remain if removed from corporate sponsorship and named for a fitting player, possibly Steve Yzerman.

2. Create the Scott Stevens trophy for greatest defensive defensemen, allowing the Norris to continue in it's tradition/tendancy to be awarded to the highest scoring d-man.

And yes, I'd rather carve my eyes out with a spork than see the Wayne Connelly Award instituted. Though I credit Bettman's giving another shot at the "if I keeps telling them how important and exciting shoouts are they'll believe me" approach.

Overall here though, let's just say that once you go over the "one stat one trophy" limit by more than oh 10 or so you've gone too far. This isn't the Boy Scouts where everyone should get numerous awards and patches for participation. :roll:
User avatar
Systemfel
Leading Scorer
Posts: 817
Joined: Sun Mar 20, 2005 5:56 pm
Location: Sweden

Post by Systemfel »

Bob Probert Belt - This award would be a championship belt like the ones worn by champions in boxing and it would be awarded each year to the NHL's most-feared fighter, the status Probert held annually during his prime in Detroit. The vote would be among all NHL players with at least three fighting majors that year. 2007 winner: Georges Laraque, Phoenix Coyotes.
No, I don't think their were written by Bettman.
User avatar
Minstrel
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 6527
Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2005 11:17 am
Custom Rank: Minty
Favourite Team: Chicago Blackhawks
Location: Chicago, Illinois

Post by Minstrel »

Systemfel wrote:
Bob Probert Belt - This award would be a championship belt like the ones worn by champions in boxing and it would be awarded each year to the NHL's most-feared fighter, the status Probert held annually during his prime in Detroit. The vote would be among all NHL players with at least three fighting majors that year. 2007 winner: Georges Laraque, Phoenix Coyotes.
No, I don't think their were written by Bettman.
Bettman's no dummy... he knows that there is no fear of ever having to award this one as he can't see there being any players with at least three fighting majors ;)
User avatar
batdad
The Great One
Posts: 12616
Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:46 pm
Custom Rank: Mr Technology
Favourite Team: Syracuse Bulldogs.
Location: Look behind you, you peon

Post by batdad »

Heh...Well stated Minty.

However, the Scott Stevens award for best defensive d-man? I have thousands of other nomineees...Langway, The Brian Engblom, Robinson, The Darian Hatcher old-NHL award. gargantuan Shinpad award, Pierre Pilotte, The Kjell Samuelsson award, Brian Glennie, and my favorite the Sheldon Kannigieser award (Love that name!!!!)

But of course, knowing Bettman it would be called the Old Milwaukee, Viagra Paul Coffey leadership award.
User avatar
Minstrel
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 6527
Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2005 11:17 am
Custom Rank: Minty
Favourite Team: Chicago Blackhawks
Location: Chicago, Illinois

Post by Minstrel »

batdad wrote:However, the Scott Stevens award for best defensive d-man? I have thousands of other nomineees...
Exactly my point, if you can't decide on one that stands out above others to name the award after and need to make a "list of thousands" of potentials you fall into the same trap. I stand by my decision to name it after Stevens who played a long and distinguished career, was a classy guy great leader and one of the most feared hitters of all time. He embodies the kind of defenseman that currently isn't given the recognition they deserve.
User avatar
batdad
The Great One
Posts: 12616
Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:46 pm
Custom Rank: Mr Technology
Favourite Team: Syracuse Bulldogs.
Location: Look behind you, you peon

Post by batdad »

Oh I know. I love Scott too. But it is because of the reasons you list that it will not happen. It is the ONE award I would like to see added, so guess what...NOPE. Best 21st man though could get added. Tomi Santala is definitely this year's winner. :-D
User avatar
Thundercleese
Minor League
Posts: 269
Joined: Tue Jan 24, 2006 10:33 pm

Post by Thundercleese »

All the trophies are great. Also, the NHL should start calling losses "deferred successes."
User avatar
flea
Team Captain
Posts: 932
Joined: Mon Feb 13, 2006 6:39 am
Custom Rank: NASCAR Racer!
Location: A Coruña, Spain
Contact:

Post by flea »

Is this list serious??? :dunno: Cant belive it!!!

The NHL has already a lot of awards....why more???

Remember: bigger (or in this case: more) doesnt equal better IMHO!!!
User avatar
Shadd666
Super Mario
Posts: 2996
Joined: Mon Mar 27, 2006 5:47 pm
Custom Rank: Smiley Crazy Goodwill Ambassador!
Location: Toulouse (France)

Post by Shadd666 »

There's only one important award: the Stanley Cup!
User avatar
Joe
Checking Line
Posts: 518
Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2006 5:53 pm
Location: Port Huron, Michigan

Post by Joe »

I agree that there needs to be 2 defense trophies, 1 for Defensive Defensmen, and 1 for Offensive Defensmen.
User avatar
Taloncarde
Drafted
Posts: 167
Joined: Sun May 01, 2005 3:24 am

Post by Taloncarde »

I was in favor when they added the Richard trophy. On one hand, i'd love to see the Gretzky trophy for assists, but, I also don't see much of the point, since typically the most points and most assists go hand in hand. not always of course, but if someone wins the ross and the gretzky every year, would not seem worth it. Now, if they did add it and you could score the "trophy hat trick" of Ross, Gretzky and Richard.... ;P
Post Reply