Montreal Canadiens: Challenge 3.2 Chat Thread

Think you're a good EHM GM? Our GM Challenges dare you to take over a team and make it a winner. The Challenge Forum and Centre are the hubs of our Challenges.

Moderator: Challenge Moderators

User avatar
Minstrel
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 6527
Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2005 11:17 am
Custom Rank: Minty
Favourite Team: Chicago Blackhawks
Location: Chicago, Illinois

Post by Minstrel »

InStaaled The thing I have to ask is; why do you let your players go released or free agent :-? They are the value of your team; you need to get something back for them! Picks, prospects, something :-o In my game I knew I'd deal Souray in the offseason due to concerns with his age, increasing tendancy to get hurt during games and his salary. But I mean jeez; ya have like five months before the next season so you sign them for the upcoming year knowing they're gone and you get their value back. Especially since Montreal gives you almost the full Cap to work under.

I knew I didn't want to take any players in the Souray deal; but most teams view him as a 4-star guy so you know you can get good value for him. I didn't get quite as much as I could have in deciding to not take roster players back but I got Philly to take him and the 2nd rounder of Anaheim and give me back their 2nd rounder, 3rd rounder and 7th rounder. I then used his salary to sign Kubina as an FA and the picks went to toward strengthening my farm. Even if those players never "make it" they'll hold trade value at least.

Only the computer and Chicago lets star players walk for nothing :roll: ](*,)
User avatar
inSTAALed
Stanley Cup Winner
Posts: 1443
Joined: Tue Jan 31, 2006 10:51 pm
Custom Rank: Back From The Dead
Location: Raleigh, NC

Post by inSTAALed »

Nobody wanted him :roll:

That was the most I could get for Souray from any team. Must have been that knee injury that required surgery at the end of the season :dunno:

I also got the most I could for Jagr. He was a 1 star for every team.

I dunno what I'm doing wrong but nobody wants my players :dunno:
User avatar
Minstrel
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 6527
Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2005 11:17 am
Custom Rank: Minty
Favourite Team: Chicago Blackhawks
Location: Chicago, Illinois

Post by Minstrel »

Okay, wait... instead of your in/out can you post your trades? The others are too confusing with the gaps I din't realize should have been picks; looked like you were just releasing people for nothing.
User avatar
inSTAALed
Stanley Cup Winner
Posts: 1443
Joined: Tue Jan 31, 2006 10:51 pm
Custom Rank: Back From The Dead
Location: Raleigh, NC

Post by inSTAALed »

Oh..

Well..

After a 0-9-0 start I got fired :cry:

Nothing would work out how I wanted to.

Then Cole got injured in my fourth game, Koivu and Cullen in the fifth, Begin in the sixth, Armstrong out for the year in 7, Kovalev out for a month in game 8.

:help:
User avatar
kuulapaa
Stanley Cup Winner
Posts: 1410
Joined: Fri Apr 28, 2006 6:14 pm
Custom Rank: General Roster Soreness
Favourite Team: Tampereen Ilves
SBHL Team: Los Angeles Kings
Location: Finland

Post by kuulapaa »

As you can see from the stats, my season #2 started well, but turned to be a bigger disaster than season #1. I'm not able to remember any more, how it all happened (and I'm not even going to try), but I'm beginning to believe it's all about my tactics. We had some injuries, but they won't explain all the poor games in our mid-season. I was really excited of my team before the season started and I still think it should be good. They just aren't playing well.

Here they are:

Cole - Koivu - Arnott
Zednik - Handzus - Ryder
Shelley - Gratton - Tucker
Louhi - Horcoff - Donovan

St.Jacques - Suchy
Mitchell - Dandenault
Alberts - Brad Brown
Bombardir

Theodore
Caron

These are just one of the few (hundred) different lines I've tried during the season. But nothing works. And here are my transfers during the season:

Code: Select all

************************************************************************************************
 Montreal Canadiens - Tuesday March 20th 2007
************************************************************************************************


================================================================================================
 2006-07 Transactions
================================================================================================

Date      Player In                From                     Fee            
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6.7.06    Jyrki Louhi              Free Transfer            Free           
6.7.06    Mattias Beck             HV71                     Free           
6.15.06   Adam Taylor              Victoria                 Ctr            
6.15.06   John Hecimovic           South Carolina           Ctr            
7.3.06    Jean-Marc Pelletier      Free Transfer            Free           
7.5.06    Danny Stewart            Free Transfer            Free           
7.5.06    Kyle Chipchura           Prince Albert            Free           
7.6.06    Andrew Ference           Flames                  Free           
7.6.06                             Flames                  Free           
7.11.06   Jason Arnott             Free Transfer            Free           
7.15.06   Evan Brophey             Blackhawks              Free           
7.23.06   Roman Tomanek            Coyotes                 Free           
7.23.06                            Coyotes                 Free           
7.26.06   Tim Konsorada            Blue Jackets            Free           
7.31.06   Vadim Prodezov           Free Transfer            Free           
7.31.06   Veli-Pekka Laakkonen     Free Transfer            Free           
8.3.06    Brent Smith              Free Transfer            Free           
10.6.06   Mike Fountain            Stars                   Free           
10.7.06   Sebastien Caron          Penguins                Free           
11.13.06  Andrew Alberts           Bruins                  Free           
11.22.06  Darcy Tucker             Canucks                 Free           
11.23.06  Shawn Horcoff            Oilers                  Free           
11.23.06                           Oilers                  Free           
11.23.06                           Oilers                  Free           
12.15.06  Scott Lynch              UBC                      Free           
12.17.06  Steve Stirling           Free Transfer            Free           
1.1.07    Adrian Foster            Devils                  Free           
1.6.07    Matt Greene              Oilers                  Free           
1.11.07   Josef Hrabal             Oilers                  Free           
1.11.07                            Oilers                  Free           
1.12.07   Brad Brown               Toronto                  Free           
1.21.07   Willie Mitchell          Oilers                  Free           
1.31.07   Drayson Connelly         Free Transfer            Free           
2.3.07    Juha Toivonen            Capitals                Free           
2.3.07                             Capitals                Free           
2.10.07   Jody Shelley             Oilers                  Free           

Date      Player Out               To                       Fee            
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6.30.06   Andrew Archer            Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Elmer Benning            Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Jonathan Ferland         Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Mathieu Garon            Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Chris Higgins            Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Jodi Van Rees            Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Jean-Philippe Cote       Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Dave Mayville            Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Matt Shasby              Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Antonin Routa            Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Hannu Laine              Released                 Free           
6.30.06   Nikolai Vakourov         Released                 Free           
7.6.06    Radek Bonk               Flames                  Free           
7.15.06   Taylor Pyatt             Blackhawks              Free           
7.23.06   Craig Rivet              Coyotes                 Free           
7.26.06                            Blue Jackets            Free           
7.26.06   Tomas Plekanec           Blue Jackets            Free           
10.7.06                            Penguins                Free           
11.13.06  Andrew Ference           Bruins                  Free           
11.23.06  Mike Ribeiro             Oilers                  Free           
11.23.06  Tim Gleason              Oilers                  Free           
11.25.06  Alexander Perezhogin     Devils                  Free           
12.16.06  Geir Tore Myhre          Released                 Free           
1.6.07    Jody Shelley             Oilers                  Free           
1.11.07   Andrei Markov            Oilers                  Free           
1.21.07                            Oilers                  Free           
2.3.07                             Capitals                Free           
2.3.07    Mike Komisarek           Capitals                Free           
Well, maybe it's good my first challenge didn't go too well. I don't have so much pressure starting the next one. You bet I don't...
User avatar
Minstrel
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 6527
Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2005 11:17 am
Custom Rank: Minty
Favourite Team: Chicago Blackhawks
Location: Chicago, Illinois

Post by Minstrel »

Guys you should post your trades pages instead of your In/Out transactions because the gaps that I assume are draft picks being empty makes the displays pretty much worthless... :dunno: or jsut take a screenshot, put hte screenie upin your Gallery and link to it; that's even easier imho.

Anyhow I've got to get to my assorted write ups this weekend... it's been a crazy week :roll: I did post my 1-20 stats today though. Read 'em and weep:

You: :blue: Me: :crown:
User avatar
Calv
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 4423
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2004 9:02 pm
Custom Rank: Goalie....Sieve....!
Favourite Team: Team GB
Location: Manchester, UK

Post by Calv »

Bonus points A have been calculated and your totals have been put into the GLR
Minstrel 18 :1st:
Bruins72 14 :2nd:
munky 8 :3rd:
Kuulapaa 5
User avatar
Minstrel
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 6527
Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2005 11:17 am
Custom Rank: Minty
Favourite Team: Chicago Blackhawks
Location: Chicago, Illinois

Post by Minstrel »

:banana: Yeah baby!
User avatar
Calv
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 4423
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2004 9:02 pm
Custom Rank: Goalie....Sieve....!
Favourite Team: Team GB
Location: Manchester, UK

Post by Calv »

Just thought I'd remind you about the next deadline
Montreal 3.2: First 60 games by 21st June
User avatar
Minstrel
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 6527
Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2005 11:17 am
Custom Rank: Minty
Favourite Team: Chicago Blackhawks
Location: Chicago, Illinois

Post by Minstrel »

I should make that one but not sure if I'll have tiome to field a St. Lousy team though as in the exact opposite of most people we have more work stuff than ever in summer as we do a lot of student workshops and such and so many people come in from other towns to work/study here over summer too that it keeps us hoppin.

I love my Montreal second season team though; never had such a talented group in a Challenge before :thup:
User avatar
Minstrel
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 6527
Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2005 11:17 am
Custom Rank: Minty
Favourite Team: Chicago Blackhawks
Location: Chicago, Illinois

Post by Minstrel »

I apologize for holding up the proceedings here; we had storms early last week that knocked out my DSL and fried my modem, so they had to send me a new one ](*,) I have gotten back up and running and got my stats in... sorry Calv. I know... :banned:

I had a kind of out of nowhere slump hit my team after probably (I haven't check for sure) one of the strongest statistical sections in Challenge history with my Games 21-40 section which was an explosion especially for my usually more low scoring teams scoring 110 goals 16-3-1. The PP was out of control as well... anyhow a much more tame 12-5-3 games 41-60 had recently come around with the deadline coming up and some deals that resolved some odd issues I had ongoing with my team. Those would need a big writeup though as this was a very non-traditional team.

Coming off our Cup win in Season 1; including carrying three goalies... leading to Cap issues causing my team to then play with a 22 player NHL roster. This was mainly due to a major FA bust signing in goal I couldn't/didn't want to deal with early on. Those goalies were integral to our "unexpected" slump... but GM Minty has resolved that now. Should be an interesting read when I get a chance to write it up.

Since I record directly here are my player numbers for 21-40 and 41-60:

21-40

30 Most Goals - Sully
35 Most Assists - Handzus
56 Most Points - Sully
28 Highest +/- - Witt
94 Most PIM - Pettinger

41-60

46 Most Goals - Sully
47 Most Assists - Handzus
85 Most Points - Sullivan
29 Highest +/- - Sullivan
120 Most PIM - Pettinger
User avatar
Calv
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 4423
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2004 9:02 pm
Custom Rank: Goalie....Sieve....!
Favourite Team: Team GB
Location: Manchester, UK

Post by Calv »

Minstrel wrote:I apologize for holding up the proceedings here; we had storms early last week that knocked out my DSL and fried my modem, so they had to send me a new one ](*,) I have gotten back up and running and got my stats in... sorry Calv. I know... :banned:
:nodice:
Bonus points have been given as so:
Minstrel 15 :1st:
Munky 13 :2nd:
Bruins72 13 :2nd:
kuulapaa 3 :3rd:

Next deadline is 7th July for your final games, see if you can meet it this time minty..... :-p
User avatar
Calv
TBL Admin Team
Posts: 4423
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2004 9:02 pm
Custom Rank: Goalie....Sieve....!
Favourite Team: Team GB
Location: Manchester, UK

Post by Calv »

Well congratulations need to go to our participants today as I finally got round to tallying all of the bonus points and improvement points!

Code: Select all

Name         Bonus Points A  Bonus Points B Season Points Improvement Points  Total
Bruins72          14              13              81                19        127
Minstrel          18              13              73                8         112
munky             8               15              58                25        106
kuulapaa          5               3               36                3         47
Points and trophies will be given out soon :thup:
Post Reply